Rethinking School Milk: What Happens When Students Get to Choose

It's incredible what change you can create with a minor shift. Bulk milk dispensers save 248 gallons of water and 30 pounds of CO₂ per student every year. These savings aren't abstract. Rather, they come from a switch that changes how students experience lunch every day. For schools balancing sustainability goals, cafeteria logistics, and student wellness, commercial milk dispensers offer a tangible solution that can positively impact all three categories. Not only can commercial milk dispensers improve traffic flow through the cafeteria, but they can also increase sustainability in schools that use them and encourage students to adopt higher levels of independence. 

‍

Why Cartons Fall Short for Students and Staff

Traditional cardboard milk cartons, which appear in schools across the country, fail to deliver on expectations not just for students, but for staff members, as well. Unfortunately, this single-use solution has created more problems than it solves for many schools.

‍

Space and Storage Challenge

Milk cartons take up massive amounts of storage space in walk-in fridges--and many schools are already short on space, especially in the 22% of schools dealing with overcrowding. Not only does that mean that those fridges often don't have enough space for the other items that cafeteria workers need to store, but it may also mean that cartons are served lukewarm due to overstocking or fridge overload. Cafeteria workers may move milk cartons out of the fridge too early to save essential space, leading to spoiled milk well before the sell-by date.

‍

Lack of Student Choice

In addition to creating storage challenges, milk cartons often remove student choice. Students are frequently handed milk that they didn't choose and don't want, especially if the school has run out of their preferred type or has a policy that every student has to take a carton of milk with their lunch. This, in turn, leads to unopened cartons that are ultimately wasted. Around 45 million gallons of milk are discarded annually--or around 32 full cartons per student, per year. Furthermore, it can increase the risk of spills, since students are careless with items they do not want.

‍

Students Drink More When Milk Is Served Cold

Cold milk isn't just important for meeting student preferences. When milk is served colder, it gets consumed more often. The National Dairy Council reports that students are more likely to drink milk when it's under 40°F.

‍

In short, kids don't drink warm milk. They toss it, unopened. It's not just the packaging that gets wasted; it's the product inside. That carton might contain the only significant source of calcium or protein in a child's meal, but most school-age children aren't thinking about that when they toss the milk into the trash. If it's not cold, it doesn't get consumed. 

‍

Unfortunately, using cartons contributes to the risk that milk will get too warm. Cartons often sit on trays or get handed out in batches. That means they warm up before they're ever touched by students. Many students choose not to ever open those warm cartons. Others may take a sip or two, but quickly fold the carton closed and toss it into the trash.

‍

Students Learn by Watching: Waste Sends a Message

Kids take in a lot about the world around them just by watching. When they see bins overflowing with unopened milk, what message does that send about the value of the product or the importance of sustainability? Using milk cartons--and accepting the associated waste--normalizes waste, not sustainability. Wasted milk produces the same emissions as 77,000 gas-powered vehicles, and the water equivalent of 10,000 Olympic-sized swimming pools. That's a lot of waste in the average cafeteria!

In contrast, bulk milk dispensers are a visible sign of change. They show students that sustainability and smarter systems matter--and that your school is committed to minimizing your environmental impact. Visible changes like bulk milk dispensers offer examples of sustainability that kids can see--and that matters a lot more than a recycling poster on the wall or a presentation around Earth Day. Students will also get to see an example of the changes they can create and embrace firsthand--right there in action every day. Often, this simple shift helps improve dedication to sustainability across the student body. The ripple effect also travels to parents, staff members, and members of the PTO or board. Over time, a simple change like installing milk dispensers can lead to a bigger commitment to sustainability across the school.

‍

Self-Serve Builds Independence and Reduces Waste

Using milk dispensers, instead of milk cartons, allows students to pour the amount they actually want. Ultimately, that leads to considerably less milk dumped down the drain--or in the trash can. Kids can take what they want, and students who do not want milk or who only want a little can select the amount that fits their needs. First and foremost, this helps students learn to listen to their own needs. Over time, they'll get a better idea of how much milk they're likely to drink with a meal and how much is going to waste. They'll appreciate the increased independence and the ability to make their own choices, rather than having specific beverage amounts forced on them. This strategy also helps kids learn to be intentional: take what you'll drink, don't waste what you won't.

When students have choice and control, consumption increases and waste decreases. Using milk dispensers mirrors strategies in other food programs that have reduced waste by up to 30% in cafeterias. This is a win for both schools and students. Decreased waste means that the school can focus more of its budget on other areas, whether that means providing more food for disadvantaged students to take home or improving the overall quality of cafeteria lunches--or dedicating that budget to another area in the school that needs it. 

‍

A Smoother, Cleaner Experience for Everyone

Using milk dispensers can provide a smoother, cleaner experience in the cafeteria for students and teachers alike. Consider the benefits from both sides.

‍

The Student Experience

Installing milk dispensers means removing the milk station from the cafeteria line--and that can make it faster and easier for students to move through the lines and get their food. That means more time for students to eat when they get back to the table. Once they arrive at the table, the reduction in spills means a cleaner, more comfortable environment.

‍

For many students, lunch is the only break they get in the day. It shouldn't be spent standing in line or trying to find a clean spot to eat on a sticky or milk-soaked table. 

‍

Imagine the student experience in a cafeteria with milk dispensers. They can enter the cafeteria and move quickly through the line, picking up their food. Then, they head over to select their milk or other beverage. Students who want more than a few ounces of milk can choose to get a larger amount, while students who do not want milk can pass on it entirely. Then, they head to a table that isn't covered with milk cartons or messes left behind by their peers in earlier classes. Students have more time to socialize and enjoy the meal that they chose. If they need a refill on their beverage, it's easy for them to stand up and go back to the milk dispenser, or to fill their cup with water from a convenient water fountain in the cafeteria. 

‍

When their lunch break is over, they're calmer and better prepared to head back to the classroom. They not only feel more supported by their school, but they're also seeing a daily representation of the school's commitment to sustainability.

‍

The Staff Experience

Students aren't the only ones who will have a better experience due to the milk dispenser installation. When you install milk dispensers in the cafeteria, you'll find that transition periods are much calmer. Staff members won't need to spend as much time hurrying in to take care of spills and messes between student groups. Janitors and other employees will spend less of their time managing sticky messes, which means more time to support students and take care of ongoing student needs. 

‍

A calmer student experience often leads to a better staff experience, too. Some staff members may go through the line with their students, picking their meals from the same selection. Others may oversee student lunchtime--and students who have a better overall lunch experience are more likely to be calm and avoid making messes. They may also need to make fewer overall demands on staff supervisors throughout the lunch period.

‍

One Small Change That Serves Students Better

Switching to a commercial milk dispenser reduces waste, simplifies operations, and improves the student experience--from what they're served to how they feel at lunch and beyond. Do you want to see how much your school could save and how much better it could serve your students? Share our impact calculator with your board, PTA, or cafeteria team. Let's give kids a better school day--one cup at a time.